Edwina has been living with her parents since she graduated from college about 2 years ago. Because her parent?

In my opinion - and this is just me- I believe it really all depends in if Edwina is saving up for something, like a house or her own apartment, and how much her parents charge her for her room. As a case of my point, if Edwina was saving up for her apartment, she would like to take out a loan, otherwise her savings would be almost absolutely gone, and so we would not wish for that to happen, would we? But if Edwina only plans on living with her parents, she might be able to pay for the car herself. After all, that leaves $500.00 for her. Now, if she was to stay with her parents - and let us asume she does indeed- then we might need to know what they ask of her to pay for her room, because she needs money for clothes, gas, emergencies, food, recreation, etc. And if her parents asked 500$ or more of her, she should get out a loan. If they ask for less than $500 dollars, i believe she'd be fine paying on her own.